left header image

Monday, March 07, 2011

You'll Want To Sit Down First

I tweet a lot at night when most of my twitter-friends* are quiet, so I was under the impression I was tweeting into the wind at night.  I assumed people were catching up with my nighttime crafting when they log into twitter in the morning.

Wednesday last week, I had an epiphany about the bust decreases and popped onto twitter to say:

I don't want to make anyone cry, but I'm pretty sure I'll be ripping out my sweater to the bust increases ... again. #YoullBeOk ;)

After I tweeted, I went back to watching something On Demand while I swatched my new decrease (yep, I mis-tweeted it as an increase).  When I popped back on twitter about 40 minutes later, I had *6* reply tweets, and I think this one sums them all up nicely:

NOOooonnOOOOOOOOOOOO!

I literally laughed out loud.  I had a feeling that people might think I'd lost my mind, but the tweets confirmed that people might start seriously considering an Unraveling Intervention.  Ha!

Hopefully you aren't too upset by this turn of events.  Or, if so, you took my advice and had a seat. :)

But after looking at the photos I took for my last Peacock Sweater, I just didn't like the way the decreases looked.  They totally shattered the beautiful wavy lines of the pattern.

Here is the old version of the decrease.  I didn't like how there was a straight vertical line in the middle with straight lines crossing it.  And then the top of the motif under the decrease is stretched  and distorts the whole motif.

I knew there had to be a better way.  I did some sketching of the motif ovals.  Just thinking about the ovals and how they could fit together to increase and decrease without compromising their edges helped me come up with a new chart.

Here is the new decrease.  I did three swatches before I came up with this one.  I never would have come up with this originally, because it goes against my intuition to have so many holes in a row.  There are 5 holes stacked on top of each other in the decrease.  But they totally work because the integrity of the wavy sides of the motifs aren't broken.

My eye is totally tricked and I don't even see the decrease.  Is it just me?

Well, OK, I see it here, but I think it looks like a part of the design and not a weird anomaly.  There is a little bit of pulling on the edges of the two motifs that border the 5th (bottom) hole in the decrease.  I tried a couple tricks to smooth that out, but they only made the motifs look more angled.

I've made some progress since these pix.  I'm now to row 37 of 52.  I'm hoping to finish the body this week.

I also reworked my charts for the hip increases so they match my new paradigm of motif integrity.  I'm really excited about this.  I feel like I've learned a new skill for modifying crochet stitch patterns.

I've also learned (for the millionth time) that I find things when I look at photos of my work that I don't see with my eyes.

As a craftsman, the moments when I feel like I've made something that is excellent in its technical execution *and* aesthetically pleasing are, well, it's hard to describe.  Those moments are both exciting and calming.  I'm pleased with my work and ready to move to the next challenge.

And you are here to witness that I'm not magically gifted.  I do a lot of work.  And, you don't even see all of the work I do.  Maybe I'm magically gifted with the desire and determination (stubbornness?) to create something awesome, but making awesome things doesn't just come naturally or easily.

This is reminding me of the art school rules I read at the Sister Corita exhibit at MOCFA when I was at Craft Bar last week.  Here's the one I'm thinking of:

Rule 7
The only rule is work.
If you work it will lead to something.
It's the people who do all of the work all of the time
who eventually catch on to things.

I feel a little weird when I say things like this.  You know, put my sense of accomplishment out here on my blog, because someone who doesn't crochet, or who crochets and just doesn't like this sweater, could look at this half-completed sweater and snort, "Haha. Oh, what a craftsman.  Riiiiiight."  And to that, I say, "Haters gonna hate."

* You can totally be one of my twitter-friends.  Follow me @futuregirlcraft.  Send me a DM so I know you're not a bot, and I'll follow you back.  xoxo!
50 Comments leave a comment


Vicki K said ...
You are right - I didn't even notice the FiveHoleStack until you featured it in the next photo. It's a graceful decrease for sure. So what is your process - do you now write down exactly what you did (and toss any other notes) and save it for making again in the future?
3/7/2011 8:46 AM

futuregirl replied ...
Vicki K ... Oh, the notes and charts deserve their own post. :)Currently, I've drawn 17 pages of charts (some are no longer used) and have written instructions that reference charts on certain pages.

During the making of this sweater, I've been mostly pre-charting. When figuring out things like this decrease, I'll chart, swatch, adjust the chart, swatch again, repeat until I'm satisfied.
3/7/2011 10:49 PM

Hope said ...
Excellent! You don't notice the decrease unless you're specifically looking for it. And I like the creative reply tweet.
3/7/2011 9:04 AM

futuregirl replied ...
Hope ... Several of the tweets had screamed "no"s :) Thanks for the decrease love.
3/7/2011 10:50 PM

My eye was totally tricked. Not being a crochet craftsman (although I did take up knitting, last weekend!), I wasn't sure what I should be looking for. In the side photo, where you're kind of tugging it down, I see it, but it totally looks natural. Almost like a bust dart or other clothing construction invention.


3/7/2011 9:31 AM

futuregirl replied ...
Lydia @ The Loop ... Thanks! I'm posting more photos tomorrow with details. You're exactly right, it looks like a natural dart. :)
3/7/2011 11:12 PM

Tove said ...
I don't comment much, but I just have to say how utterly impressed I am by your patience. If it were me, I'd have tossed out the whole project long ago. I think your new decrease really works with the pattern, and it looks great. It's not something you spot unless your actively looking for it. That said, I kind of liked the heartshape of the previous one as well.

I've mostly knitted in the past, but the last few months I've been crocheting a lot. It's so fun, and a bit more portable than knitting when traveling to and from work (especially since I've been hooking small projects like snowflakes, small amigurumi and blanket squares). I really like your blog, it's a great inspiration (for all types of crafty goodness). Thanks for sharing!
3/7/2011 9:44 AM

futuregirl replied ...
Tove ... Thank you so much for the wonderful comment! Crochet is really awesome for portability and small projects. :) Glad you're enjoying it.
3/7/2011 11:15 PM

Suzie said ...
Well, I'm a non-crocheter who has nevertheless followed the progress of your Peacock Sweater. No hate here--I'm always amazed by how much work you put into your pieces and how thoughtfully you make adjustments. Even though I don't understand the crochet, I can see the changes in the work and am always inspired by your willingness to persist until something feels just right to you. Please keep doing what you do!
3/7/2011 9:44 AM

futuregirl replied ...
Suzie ... Thank you, Suzie! I appreciate your non-crocheter perspective. :)
3/7/2011 10:51 PM

Donna said ...
So cool. This is how much I know about crocheting; in that I couldn't see a difference between the two pic's. They both looked beautiful.
After a 2nd look, the 2nd one did look smoother, I suppose, lol.
Ah, to have such talent!
:)
3/7/2011 10:04 AM

futuregirl replied ...
Donna ... Haha! Well, you're not the only one that had trouble seeing the difference, so I'm posting some annotated photos tomorrow. :)
3/7/2011 10:51 PM

I am REALLY trying, but I don't see the difference either and I want to because it was so obvious to you, but I really don't see it at all. *hangs head in shame*
3/7/2011 10:38 AM

futuregirl replied ...
Mutantsupermodel ... Oh, man, no need to feel shame! Thank goodness you have the guts to ask. I'm posting some photos with notes tomorrow. :)
3/7/2011 10:52 PM

Miss Lizzy said ...
It is fascinating as a newish crocheter (one year and self taught...)to see this type of project. I don't even pretend to understand the stitch symbols. In the bottom of a box I have a beautiful crocheted blouse that I was to replicate and this has helped a lot.

3/7/2011 11:17 AM

futuregirl replied ...
Miss Lizzy ... Thanks! Good luck with your project, once you undertake it. :)
3/7/2011 10:53 PM

I agree with Suzie. I have just learned to crochet and am at the ABC stage, so when I read about the amount of work you put into making a complicated piece work for you, it's like watching a writer edit and edit and edit again until a piece flows seemlessly. Wonderful. And all the things that look amazing and effortless require lots and lots of work, so good that you keep putting that out there. Claire
3/7/2011 11:46 AM

futuregirl replied ...
noknittedknickers ... Thank you for the sweet comment. :)
3/7/2011 6:21 PM

I think it's great that you've shared this. Most crocheters don't know quite how much work goes into making a pattern. Some think that it's probably not that much. Others think that it's so hard that it's impossible for a normal person to do it. The answer clearly lies in between and stories like yours help to clear this up.
3/7/2011 12:24 PM

futuregirl replied ...
CrochetBlogger ... Thank you for the great comment!
3/7/2011 6:20 PM

Birdy said ...
FG, if there is one thing you've taught me (there isn't just one, you've taught me a lot!) it's that ripping something out is never a bad thing! It's a learning experience and it just assures that your project will turn out perfect, instead of so-so.

I really like the second go through, and I can not wait to see this sweater finished. It already looks awesome on you.
3/7/2011 1:07 PM

futuregirl replied ...
Birdy ... Gah! Thanks, Birdy!
3/7/2011 6:15 PM

Nicole said ...
Thank you for being brave and willing to show your missteps and impulses to unravel everything. I think that as so many of us craft in the late evenings or wee hours of the morning, it is easy to forget that we are not alone and lots of other people are getting frustrated with their work, but that some distance can give us some good perspective.
3/7/2011 1:51 PM

jessyz said ...
I am so going to cry if you unravel any more of this. I have been watching this sweater since it was the chain mail sweater I think
3/7/2011 2:08 PM

futuregirl replied ...
jessyz ... You'll be OK. **big hug!** Promise. :)
3/7/2011 6:14 PM

MummyCat said ...
I love your design process. You keep at it until you find the right way. It looks beautiful!
3/7/2011 2:12 PM

Kuky said ...
Nooooooooooo!!! ;-D I am hanging my head in shame too. I don't see the difference either. Neither does Alan. Because, yes, I pulled him over to the computer to see if it was just me. Granted he doesn't knit or crochet so I didn't really expect him to see it.
3/7/2011 2:57 PM

futuregirl replied ...
Kuky ... Haha, you're not the only one. I'll post some photos with arrows. :)
3/7/2011 6:13 PM

jessica said ...
I do see the five holes your talking about but I kinda like the elongated effect the decreases have on the cluster of motifs. You get bonus points for the decreases. I would have thought that the stitch pattern you created would have stretched at the bust then snugged back at the waist by itself and only required increases at the hips.
3/7/2011 3:04 PM

futuregirl replied ...
jessica ... Just to be clear, I didn't design this stitch, I got it from a stitch dictionary. :) Crochet isn't very stretchy, no matter what you do, and in the case of this stitch, it's stretchier up/down than side-to-side, so I'm doubly challenged with trying to fit my curves.

I prefer my tops to be form fitting because I otherwise come out looking like a pyramid with my head at the top point and my hips at the base. There are probably many people who would be fine with (and look great, too) the top not hugging their ... upper curves. :)
3/7/2011 6:12 PM

Keri said ...
Excellent work keeping at it. The perfectionist in me applauds this extreme effort. It's a lovely decrease. I'm pretty certain I'd have given up!
3/7/2011 5:23 PM

Korina said ...
Long time lurker here. I'm not only impressed with the amount and quality of your work, I'm highly impressed with how well the yarn is holding up!

I love the new decrease; it's genius. They say genius is blindingly obvious afterward.

Korina
3/7/2011 7:18 PM

futuregirl replied ...
Korina ... Nice to meet you! I *know*! Is this yarn amazing or what?! And to know it's washable and dry-able ... well, it's just about perfect. :) Thanks for the decrease love.
3/7/2011 11:02 PM

Kavitha said ...
Excellent work! The whole Peacock Sweater story is like a course material on "Crochet Stitch Pattern -> Elegant Garment." My Bows to all the documentation effort and the wonderful inspiration.
3/7/2011 10:17 PM

futuregirl replied ...
Kavitha ... Why, thank you, dear! What a sweet comments!
3/7/2011 11:03 PM

pxl8 said ...
re: your footnote - people you're not following can't DM you, apparently ;)
http://support.twitter.com/articles/14606-what-is-a-direct-message-dm
3/8/2011 12:31 AM

futuregirl replied ...
pxl8 ... Oops! People seem to figure it out and just send me tweets. Did you? :)
3/15/2011 7:47 PM

Heidi said ...
Oh my. I would be in tears by now. Hats off to you!
3/8/2011 8:02 AM

Sister Diane said ...
I love your approach to your craft, Alice - and it always shows in the finished product. I'm such a process-crafter, I never go back and re-do anything. So I'm always fascinated by your detailed thought processes and careful back-up-and-try-agains. This sweater just gets more and more beautiful.
3/8/2011 8:11 AM

futuregirl replied ...
Sister Diane ... Thanks! It's funny, I'm a process crafter, too, but we're different kinds of process crafters. There should be some kind of chart. :)
3/15/2011 8:26 PM

Charlotte said ...
Looking great! I didn't notice the holes until you pointed them out. The design just nicely flows along. I'm impressed ;) And even more impressed with your determination. I probably would have torn it all apart by now...

Do you write down your patterns in words or do you draw them out like the Japanese crochet patterns? I've always wondered how to make pattern charts like that :D

BTW, your Sterling handbag pattern is my current train project. Every day I travel a minimum of 3 hours a day by train to go to work and I don't always want to read, so since I started crocheting, I often take a project with me. The handbag is an excellent project for the train :D
3/9/2011 2:03 AM

futuregirl replied ...
Charlotte ... Thanks for the sweet comment! Sometimes I write out the pattern and sometimes I draw a diagram. It depends on what is easiest to describe the thing I'm crocheting. For this sweater, I have a sentence for each section that directs me to the right diagram for the part I'm making.

I'd love to see your Starling, if you want to send me pix when you're done!
3/15/2011 11:31 PM

kingshearte said ...
Just seconding (or thirding, or twelfthing, or whatever) the kudos to your patience. As much as we all *know* that if there's something that bothers us, we'll just never wear the piece, no matter how long it took, it's still very tempting to just carry on and pretend it doesn't bother us. And then, of course, we never wear the piece. So congrats on your intense dedication to doing this right.

Your new decrease looks fab. I think it definitely looks better than the previous one. I saw it, because it's kind of what the post was about, but on a casual glance? No one will even notice, it integrates that seamlessly. Nice job!
3/9/2011 8:15 AM

futuregirl replied ...
kingshearte ... I'm like that with regular clothes, too. I know if I have a hesitation in the store, that I'll never ever wear it. No different with the stuff I make. :) Or so I think since I've never really made anything I actually wear. Well, there's Ponchi, but I don't think he counts ... ha! Don't tell him I said that. (p.s. Thanks for the sweet comment!)
3/15/2011 11:33 PM

Deepa M. said ...
LOL - I totally agree with that tweet!! I admire your tenacity in figuring out the sweater and having to frog those complicated motifs SO many times .... I think you're making a "million dollar sweater" :) I hope this time is the charm - from the pictures it looks awesome so far!
3/10/2011 7:03 AM

futuregirl replied ...
Deepa M. ... Ha! It's probably taken me a million dollars' worth of hours to make the sweater. :) Thanks for the sweet comment.
3/15/2011 11:34 PM

pxl8 said ...
yes, I figured it out :)
3/15/2011 8:45 PM

futuregirl replied ...
pxl8 ... Good! I looked for your twitter on your blog. I was going to follow you if I hadn't already. Yay!
3/15/2011 11:38 PM

Resmi said ...
The top looks real pretty!!!
4/29/2011 8:32 AM
 
Abi said ...
Smooth! It's great to know that I'm not alone in still learning while I'm designing patterns. Thank you.
6/3/2011 2:42 PM

YOUR FIRST COMMENT MUST BE MANUALLY APPROVED


Leave A Commentprivacy policy 

Name


Email won't be displayed publicly


Website must start with http://


remember my info for next time

Comment html tags not allowed


Robot FoilerEnter the text from the image into the box.
get new image