Wednesday, January 20, 2010

Challenge 2009 - Conclusions

I kinda, sorta hoped to do this wrap up right at the end of 2009, but since I didn't even announce the challenge until January 15th of 2009, it seems fitting that my wrap up is mid-month, too.

Background

My Challenge 2009 was to only use what I had in my craft stash for a whole year.  My goal was to spend zero dollars on craft supplies, but I did give myself a$2/month allowance ($24 for the year) just in case I needed something I just couldn't do without to finish a project.

I did this because I had a lot of really awesome supplies that I'd had for YEARS that I really wanted to use. On top of that, the economic downturn was starting to worry me and I didn't want to spend any time stressing over *how much* crafty spending was *too much*.

How It All Shook Out

I'll be honest, I thought this was going to be easy.  And it kind of was.  There were times when I was tempted to go *buy something* just to *buy something*, but I resisted.  It helped that I had an amazing stash, that I got a couple gift-boxes of supplies from blog-friends, and that publishers sent me review copies of some very excellent books.

To say I had no idea what 2009 had in store for me is an Epic Understatement. Twelve months, 2,000 miles, and 3 apartments later, I'm actually proud that I only spent $5.66.  If it weren't for all the moving, which meant being separated from most of my stash, I know I would have spent nothing.

Conclusions

Well, I am much less likely to buy things now.  My first impulse when starting a project used to be to go shopping.  Now my first impulse is to look in my stash.  That's an awesome change.  I actually had to remind myself the other day that it was OK to go get a skein of yarn to make my 'hog.  I was trying to convince myself that using the blue yarn I already had would be fine. :)

An unexpected  realization is eloquently put in Lauren's comment on this sweater post:
I think the restraint has really brought out your creativity-- I love seeing this sweater transform after each trial, and I really am loving this honeycomb effect. I think the sweater is turning out really cute, and you might never have gotten this far if you could have just bought a different yarn!

I had been so absorbed in the process, that I hadn't examined what was going on.  After reading that comment, I went back and looked at the photos of the original sweater and the photos of the final sweater.  The original sweater is OK, but the final sweater knocks my socks off.

How many crafty challenges had I solved by buying more supplies instead of actually confronting the challenge?  Is the key to growing as a creator to make myself do hard things without taking the easy way out?  What kind of things can I continue to do to keep myself on this path?  I don't have the answers to these questions right now, but asking them is an important part of the process, too.

Looking Forward

I don't think I'll have formal Challenge 2010, but I *do* have some ideas about where my focus should be in the coming year.  I've been letting ideas rattle around in my head the last month or so.  I'll get all my thoughts together and post about them soon.

What do you think?  Do you have any suggestions about what you'd like to see me doing on futuregirl?  Are there any unfinished projects that you are hoping I'll finish sooner than later?
15 Comments leave a comment


Joanne said ...
I think that the entire process was fascinating. It helped me be reminded that we MAKE and CREATE because of what it means to us, and because of what we can give to others, and teach to others, rather than how many gadgets, supplies, and pretty things we can buy for each project that we begin. As I'm re-doing my craft studio, I'm finding that I have SO MANY SUPPLIES that have been purchased, stashed away, and forgotten. It's time to be truly creative and use what we ALREADY HAVE before spending more... especially when so many in the world around us have SO VERY LITTLE.
1/20/2010 1:10 PM

Heather said ...
Your 2009 craft challege actually inspired me to try it myself for this year. Those darn 50% coupons can be so tempting though but I realized lately I was using them as an excuse to buy *something* rather than saving on something I *needed*. I have plenty of yarn and supplies to last me the year. I am going to give it a go.
1/20/2010 1:21 PM

Vicki K said ...
Did you really move Three times? Argh... Sometimes I forgot you were on The Plan and was amazed by your persistence to get something right (like the sweater). Sometimes I would like to know what it would feel like to walk into a yarn or fabric store knowing that I was perfectly ready for new supplies...
1/20/2010 1:37 PM

Bindu said ...
I am glad that you did the challenge. Now I am making a blanket to use up my yarns. It is not finished yet. My new job will take much of my time. But I will be finishing the blanket.
Thank you for the inspiration!!!
1/20/2010 2:29 PM

Kristine said ...
I just found your site and was so excited. What a great challenge. I have stash like you wouldn't believe. I think that will be my challenge for this year. Like Heather said, "Those darn 50% coupons can be so tempting". And I agree. But now I have a challenge. Let's see how I do.....
1/20/2010 3:44 PM

nancymoo said ...
I agree with Lauren! Watching your creativity explode has been so inspiring! My stash is so plentiful and I know there are so many things I could create from it. Thanks sharing this experience with us! :D
1/20/2010 5:49 PM

Eleanor said ...
I have to say a great big thank-you, both for the 2009 challenge and for this wrap up post. I really appreciate the insights you shared and am sure that I will think of you, and then think twice, everytime I hit the craft/yarn/fabric store from now on...something my family, my house, and my pocketbook will greatly enjoy :-)
1/20/2010 9:53 PM

Kathy said ...
Hi FutureGirl! I am currently challenging myself to use what I have before I buy any more craft supplies. This has been very satisfying, b/c I am now a guilt free crafter! And I agree with you, in that it is also a challenge to be a little bit more creative. There is nothing more satisfying than using up all of your extra yarn...or fabric! :)
1/20/2010 10:57 PM

Miho said ...
What a fantastic idea, it's certainly something I am going to try myself.

It's crazy how many of us have vast collections of supplies, yet purchase more -I'm certainly guilty of that!

As for everyone else who has decided to challenge themselves, I'd love to hear of your progress.

1/20/2010 11:59 PM

est said ...
that is really one meaningful piece of your wrap up about your amazing challenge which is 'still' to me one big impossible challenge to take up. buying just because of 'owning' is my one big flaw. my stash is my 'collection'. and i had to admit i have this never-enough-buying-collection greedy kinda syndrome. and sometimes i really hate it . the after 'urge' of buying and owning the whole set of something and then only realised what a waste of $ and storage!just like a very bad hangover. or am i making lame excuses.

but i'm learning to be a wise spender more and more. especially on fabrics! top wallet killer in my craft alley :/

thanks alice for showing me nothing is impossible.

1/21/2010 1:34 AM

SofiAlgarvia said ...
Olá, Alice!
I follow your blog from Portugal for a month or so, and I find here much inspiration for my crafts. I'm having much fun seeing how you're planning your peacock sweater.
And this challenge you had for 2009 was amazing! You must have made huge effort not to buy anything, and not even to approach a yarn store, didn't ya?
I wish you all the best for 2010 and, if you don't mind, I'll stick around to watch your creativity.

1/21/2010 6:01 AM

Tammy said ...
That's amazing that you were able to spend close to nothing. I've been inspired over the last few years to use more and more of just what I have - and finally! am having fun with it. Just organizing and looking through my stuff has been great.

I love your blog and always enjoy seeing what you do next.
1/22/2010 1:58 AM

HildeC said ...
It's very interesting to hear your thoughts on how the 2009 challenge went. When I first heard about the challenge you had set for yourself, I thought that I was glad it wasn't me. To have that restraint sounded awful to me. But then I end up with way more stash than I need, which I also think is a problem. With you writing that this restraint has made new creative pathways for you, I think I should be more strict with what I buy, and see what happens :-)
1/22/2010 6:19 AM

Lauren said ...
Ahhh!! I would have commented about this post much sooner, but the funny thing is, on the day you wrote this post I was in the hospital getting an appendectomy! Crazy, huh? Maybe that's why you were thinking of me. ;)

Well, the appendectomy sucked, but being mentioned in your blog made my day!!! (eating solid foods today comes in a close second)

I am always telling my boyfriend "Futuregirl said this" and "Futuregirl did that" so I feel a little bit famous now. I'm glad that I helped you think more about your challenge because it was very inspiring to me, and obviously to a lot of people!

Keep up the good work! Maybe we can see a Julie and Julia type deal coming from your blog one day? I would be HAPPY to participate in that; I was in a school play once. ;)
1/22/2010 7:16 PM
 
pam said ...
I immediately adopted your challenge to yourself last year to craft from your stash! I can tell you that my husband is thrilled with the idea and hopes that I will continue following in your footsteps this year too!

I have learned to improvise and I have learned to buy only what I have a specific need or use for. And I have been able, with your help, to stop impulse buying almost 100%!

So, from me, and from my sweetie, thank you!
1/23/2010 5:48 PM

YOUR FIRST COMMENT MUST BE MANUALLY APPROVED


Leave A Commentprivacy policy 

Name


Email won't be displayed publicly


Website must start with http://


remember my info for next time

Comment html tags not allowed


Robot FoilerEnter the text from the image into the box.
get new image