left header image

Monday, May 17, 2010

First Knitted Sweater

I'm still under a pile of to-do lists *and* I have 605 emails in my inbox to go through *and* I have responded to NOT ONE of the sweet comments from my last post ... but instead of feeling overwhelmed and putting blogging off until I feel like things are on an even keel, I'm just going to jump right back in.

This weekend I finished up my first knitted sweater.  It's awful.

First, I want to say, "I don't hate my body."  That said, my hip measurement is 6" bigger than my bust measurement.  Luckily, I have a waist, so if I wear tight clothes that hug my waist I can create the illusion that I'm hourglass-shaped.  If my top goes right from my shoulders to my hips without defining my  waist in any way, I become a pyramid; a pointy head on top and wide hips at the base. And that's what happens with this sweater.

It's like an instant 15 pound weight gain.  Argh.  The sweater is too big, which is the first problem.  I knew my gauge was a little bigger than the one in the pattern, so I made the small instead of the medium.  It was kinda hard to guess about finished size, though, because you only know the actual sweater width at the end when you on-purpose cause the runs.

The other problem is I don't think this is a good garment shape for me, which is the reason I'm not going to try again to make this in a smaller size.  Looking at my wardrobe, all my favorite shirts have wide scoop necks, deep v-necks, or tight crew necks.  The wide, almost boat-neck opening doesn't work well with my sloping shoulders.

There are plenty of people that look awesome in this sweater (evidence: ravelry accidentally on purpose sweater page, so don't let my failure influence you if you're planning on trying this out.

I modded the neck in an effort to mitigate the boat neck issue, which is why my runs disappear.  I re-knit this bit several times to try and create a nicer opening.  I did a good job of tightening up the neck line and fashioning some straps, but I just couldn't save the sweater.

I *totally* know how to knit and purl now, though.  Which is awesome!  I've adopted Continental knitting with the help of this amazing knitting video.
44 Comments leave a comment


Lauren said ...
Well, even though the sweater doesn't look good on, the sweater itself looks excellent! The knits and purls are lovely and even!

I am really impressed to see you tried a sweater. I have been knitting for four years and I am just now starting my first adult-sized sweater. They're scary because you don't want to put all that work in and get a bad result! But you can't succeed if you don't even try, so I think you get bonus points for trying.

And if you don't like the results, you still learned a lot from the process and will do that much better next time. (I am encouraged to keep working on my sweater, surely something good will come out of it!)
5/18/2010 1:38 AM

futuregirl replied ...
Lauren ... You're right, I learned a lot! My ending knits and purls are even, but the beginning rows (and the whole back, really) are a mess. :) It doesn't really matter though, because of the runs. It's supposed to be a little sloppy.

I might wear it around the house in the winter to keep warm ... we'll see ... a sweater won't get in the sink like a poncho does when you're doing the dishes.
5/18/2010 1:53 AM

Papgena said ...
The sweater it is beautiful, like the colors. Can't you wear a belt with it to mark your waist? you can do one... ;)
Seems a waist not to use your creation!
5/18/2010 3:16 AM

futuregirl replied ...
Papgena ... I'm afraid a belt would make me look like a two sausage links. :) haha!
5/18/2010 2:16 PM

lizardgirl said ...
It's brilliant! It is lovely - great colours. I'm sure someone you know would love to wear it. I know how disappointed you must be when you have spent all that time knitting and are not happy with the result - I knitted 2 similar shape tops, one was way too loose and one i totally ruined the neckline on. Great idea to go with what shapes you have already in your wardrobe. Enjoy your next project!
5/18/2010 5:08 AM

futuregirl replied ...
lizardgirl ... I don't know why I didn't think about the garment shape first. I did when I started making the peacock sweater. I think I thought knitting was magical and would fit just right no matter what. :)
5/18/2010 2:17 PM

Michelle said ...
Great job on the sweater! i still can't get past the basic stitches of knitting. I'm sure your next one will be perfect!
5/18/2010 7:31 AM

futuregirl replied ...
Michelle ... Thanks for the vote of confidence! I hope you're right. :)
5/18/2010 2:20 PM

Betsy ( the cramped hand) said ...
You did a great job. Almost all the knitters I know frogged there first sweater.Mine looked like the top of the sweater and the bottom were knit for 2 different people.So hang in there and try again.
5/18/2010 7:48 AM

futuregirl replied ...
Betsy ... Thanks! Good to know we're all in same wonky sweater boat. :)
5/18/2010 2:21 PM

Tara said ...
I think it looks good. One of the first things I knitted was a sweater, too. Just jump right in there is my philosophy.

Thanks for the video link. I'm definitely changing to continental style, the transitions are so much easier.
5/18/2010 9:58 AM

futuregirl replied ...
Tara ... I can't even imagine having to switch between k and p when you're throwing English. s. l. o. w. :)
5/18/2010 2:23 PM

SofiAlgarvia said ...
I think you may add a belt to it. Make the sweater a little longer and use it with a large belt. Wear it a little bit under your waist.
Don't waist such a lovely sweater! :)
5/18/2010 10:32 AM

futuregirl replied ...
SofiAlgarvia ... I think I'll wear the sweater around the house. I'm not much of a belt person. Someone suggested shrinking it, so I'll try that.
5/18/2010 2:25 PM

SofiAlgarvia said ...
Don't waste such a lovely sweater! (Sorry!)
5/18/2010 10:33 AM

UK lass in US said ...
That's why I've been avoiding knitting anything for myself - I'm such a slow knitter that I think that I'd be heartbroken to spend all that time knitting only to find that I didn't like the end result.
5/18/2010 12:05 PM

futuregirl replied ...
UK lass in US ... I think the key is going to be picking the right garment shape and making a top-down sweater so I can try it on as I go. If I'm not making sweaters, I'm not sure what I'd knit ... I'm not a shawl-person.
5/18/2010 2:26 PM

Angela said ...
... but you completed it! That's exciting in itself. I've gotta say, you definitely inspired me to learn to knit and I'm working on my first sweater now. So, thanks!
5/18/2010 12:42 PM

futuregirl replied ...
Angela ... That's awesome! Good luck on your first sweater. :)
5/18/2010 2:27 PM

anilia said ...
can weave a drawstring into the sweater about an inch or so above where your jeans hit? I think it would totally work and also try the belt thing. Don't just assume it wont work- i have the same shape and have just started using belt on everything.
5/18/2010 4:45 PM

futuregirl replied ...
anilia ... OK, you convinced me. :) I'll give it a try.
5/20/2010 3:29 PM

nancymoo said ...
Wow! Awesome job, even if you don't like the fit. I haven't had the guts to knit a whole anything!! I have a friend who has recommended continental style to me as a fellow crocheter, but I haven't gotten her to teach me yet. Your video link might be just what I need!!
My main problem is that I'm really good at crochet, so I just do that instead... I need to suck it up and DO IT. Thanks for the inspiration! :D
5/18/2010 7:40 PM

futuregirl replied ...
nancymoo ... Well, you don't actually HAVE to knit. And I can't wait to get back to my crochet projects!
5/20/2010 3:30 PM

Miranda said ...
Hello, hello! I just stumbled upon your site and had a great time reading some post. :) Just wanted to let you know that I think the sweater looks great, even if it doesn't look that great on you. You did a nice job on it! I haven't knitted any clothing pieces yet...just scarves mostly. I started a hat but I took it all out because I was having trouble getting the gauge with the yarn I had. :) Knitting is really fun though! My most ambitious project so far was a one of those knitted towels that hangs on a stove handle for my mom for mother's day. I hope to knit some clothing soon though. :)

Love the blog though! I think I will poke around and read more. :D
5/18/2010 9:30 PM

futuregirl replied ...
Miranda ... Thank you for your sweet comment about my sweater! I'm glad you like my blog, too. :)
7/15/2010 10:48 PM

Cindabella said ...
I love the idea of the dropped stitches it looks so cool. Thanks so much for the link to Ravelry as well, I had never heard of it and can't wait to get home from work to load all my projects. It amazes me the number of people working on the same pattern as me.
5/18/2010 11:40 PM

futuregirl replied ...
Cindabella ... I'm so happy to have introduced you to Ravelry! It's a great place. I don't use it as much as I should.
5/20/2010 3:31 PM

Connie Turner said ...
I think the problem is the stripes - horizontal and at the hip line so make you look wider. Sweater looks great.

5/19/2010 1:12 PM

futuregirl replied ...
Connie ... I'm gonna disagree. :) I love horizontal stripes and, even at the hip, I think they're fine if the fit is right. If you could see a side and back view, you'd see all the extra fabric billowing around my mid-section. I think the belt suggestions from other commenters might save this sweater.
5/20/2010 3:35 PM

futuregirl replied ...
Tina ... I was actually thinking the same thing! I'll try them both out and see if either makes the fit better. Thanks!
5/20/2010 3:36 PM

Tina said ...
I like the drawstring idea but I would put it up higher for an empire waist. As a similar shaped (hips larger than bust) woman, I find the high waist actually accentuates the bust and minimizes hips as long as the hem does't go across the widest part of your hips...
5/19/2010 3:44 PM

Tara said ...
I agree with Tina. Make a blue i-cord and weave in under the bust. I think that would look cute.
5/20/2010 9:08 AM

futuregirl replied ...
Tina ... I'll see how that looks. You've all convinced me to at least try. :)
5/20/2010 3:37 PM

pam said ...
A cord woven through the stitches at the waist was the very first thing I thought of too!

But - I just have to say, beautiful job for your first knitted garment. You are brilliant! This is lovely. I am still struggling with booties and YO's and you have created this beauty. Bravo you!
5/20/2010 8:10 PM

futuregirl replied ...
Pam ... Thanks! Although, I haven't done anything fancy like heels or YOs at all. The sweater is just two big rectangles, which is why I picked it. :)
5/21/2010 6:03 PM

Rorra said ...
I knit the same pattern as my first sweater and had the exact same problem! Something that I've learned is to use the finished measurements that the schematics give you. Two really good books on sweater shaping are "Big Girl Knits" and "More Big Girl Knits". Even if you are not in the plus size category it gives you a lot of good information on emphasizing what you like about your figure, and downplaying what you don't.
5/21/2010 5:47 PM

futuregirl replied ...
Rorra ... Thanks for the book recommendation! I'll check it out. :) Did you ever try the sweater again? Did you try a belt? Just wondering.
5/21/2010 6:04 PM

Nikki said ...
Wow! I still think you did an excellent job. I just finished my first sweater and blogged a pic on my site. It's RIDDLED with mistakes but regardless, it's still an accomplishment on my part - as this is on yours! I do like the pattern you chose! Great color choices as well!!!
5/22/2010 9:27 PM

carly said ...
wow, what a lovely sweater, the knitting is so neat and the colours look fab together. i just can't get enough patience for knitting something so big, no matter how much i try! might sound strange, but could you try it tucked in to a high-waisted skirt, maybe with a long sleeved blouse underneath it?
5/23/2010 5:34 PM

Laura said ...
I had the same problem with a top I bought... I fastened it at the back with an elastic band and hid the bunch under the top and secured it with a pin...
So far with knitting I've managed a place-mat and a coaster!
5/24/2010 4:25 AM

Laura Cruz said ...
Awesome! I really want to knit/crochet a sweater but I always get so intimidated by them, gah! :-)
5/24/2010 8:52 PM

skhan said ...
Sorry girls, but I didn't notice a problem with the sweater until I read the post =p
Alice you can send me the sweater if you are finding it way too big =D

And you are such a quick learner, I can't believe you have finally made your first knitted sweater! YAY!

5/26/2010 6:51 AM

val said ...
I have the same body type. Maybe you could add a scallop to the bottom edge of the top for a wee bit more length then add a long broomstick style skirt to it. That look would work well with your body type because it lengthens everything. Finish it off with some sandals and grab a margarita!
5/29/2010 2:17 PM
 
futuregirl replied ...
val ... Yes! The finishing touch on every sweater should be an awesome, fruity drink! :) You crack me up! Thanks for the awesome comment! (and excuse my tardiness in acknowledging it.)
6/23/2010 9:21 PM

YOUR FIRST COMMENT MUST BE MANUALLY APPROVED


Leave A Commentprivacy policy 

Name


Email won't be displayed publicly


Website must start with http://


remember my info for next time

Comment html tags not allowed


Robot FoilerEnter the text from the image into the box.
get new image